《核磁共振成像-物理原理和脉冲序列设计》书评

Not my first choice

The one whos wants to develop more skills on pulse sequence design can go to see a more detail deccription of pulse sequence : Handbook of MRI Pulse Sequences. You will benefits a lot from it.This book talk about the sequence from the basic to practice, however, reader usually can not find the relationship between different sequence which is most important in pulse sequence study. We'd better find more detail about a sequence before put into practical in a hurry.

the classic one

@amazon.You would understand why those books are becoming master pieces and why those authors are becoming masters.For beginners.这是对原版的评价。对于中文译本，感到比较失望。1.翻译水准一般，基本通畅。2.不少翻译欠妥，有些对图的说明的翻译令人迷惑。3.很多公式印刷错误。从风格上看，大概是word排版的；公式美观程度和原书的latex不能比，还在其次。主要是公式错误太多，作为一本在MRI基本原理的经典教科书（的中译本），公式错，你认为是什么意思？这不是霍金的《时间简史》，只需要一个公式。把公式去掉，教科书就没有意义了。印刷有错误的公式估计有10%~15%吧。总结起来，没有原版参考，很难读通。综上，我认为翻译作品“雅”的程度和译者的语文功底有关，对于数理理论方面的译作，不可强求，但是“信”和“达”是至少要保证的。我也理解，译者不可能发现书中所有的错误，而这正是审校存在意义。现在图书的审校存在严重问题，令人悲哀。作为对比，我也看到近来一些心理学方面的译作翻译流畅，读来让人舒服的。